WGF Testimony to JCRAR on CWD Emergency Rules
Tom HaugeWI Green Fire, October 1, 2018
To: Members – Joint Committee on Review of Administrative Rules (JCRAR)
Re: Emergency Rule Suspension
I’m writing to inform committee members that Wisconsin’s Green Fire believes the emergency rules on deer fencing and deer carcass transport are science-based and will help reduce human assisted spread of chronic wasting disease (CWD). Current science demonstrates that once CWD becomes established in wild deer populations it is extremely difficult to eliminate and over time will substantially reduce our deer herds and hunting opportunities. As a result, preventing the spread of CWD should be a top priority for our state. The proposed emergency rules on Deer Farm Fencing and Deer Carcass Transport are important steps in a prevention strategy.
Fencing Research has clearly documented that CWD is readily spread through animal to animal contact. Saliva is known to be one of the most infectious secretions from infected deer. Current state deer farm fencing requirements do not create a sufficient barrier to prevent contact between deer farm animals and wild deer inhabiting adjacent lands. Unfortunately, physical contact of wild and captive deer across fences does occur. This pathway of infection is an important risk both for healthy, CWD-free wild herds where CWD-positive deer farms exist, as well as, to healthy, CWD-free captive herds that reside in areas where CWD has been found in wild deer. The emergency rule adopted by the Natural Resources Board greatly reduces the likelihood of transmission by creating a physical separation between captive and wild deer.
Transport Research has also clearly documented that healthy deer can become infected through contact with CWD-contaminated environments. Carcasses of CWD-positive deer can be a significant source of infectious material including brain, muscle, nerve, and lymph tissues. If infected carcasses are deposited upon the landscape, they can contaminate that location. These carcasses are also consumed by a variety of scavengers that can spread infectious prions over a larger area. It is clear from Wisconsin’s deer harvest records that many deer are taken within the heavily CWD-infected areas by hunters that live in other portions of the state (as well as other states) where surveillance has not yet detected CWD in wild deer. Please see the attached map shared by the Quality Deer Management Association. We need to ensure the proper disposal of these carcasses. The emergency rule directs that any deer carcasses removed from counties within our heavily CWD infected areas be taken to licensed meat processors and taxidermists. Both these entities have waste disposal requirements that can properly contain the infected materials.
Legislative CWD Assistance
We appreciate JCRAR’s interest in CWD management. The following are actions your committee could take to improve Wisconsin’s response to minimize the negative impacts of this disease:
- We need to halt the building of CWD super-fund sites in Wisconsin. Your committee should communicate with the Legislature’s Joint Finance Committee and the Governor’s Office to ensure the next state budget contains adequate funding to indemnify CWDpositive captive herds so that they can be depopulated immediately. Allowing these herds to remain not only increases the environmental contamination within these farms, it raises the risk to surrounding CWD-free wild deer herds.
- Your committee should investigate what administrative rules or statutes, if any, are preventing Wisconsin’s waste disposal sites from accepting deer carcasses. As soon as possible and no later than the 2019 deer hunting season, we need to make it possible for every Wisconsin hunter to dispose of their deer carcass in a licensed landfill or incinerator. If you can achieve this, carcass movement restrictions could be eliminated.
Thank you for consideration of our comments.
Tom Hauge Tom Hauge, Cochair – Wildlife Work Group
Wisconsin’s Green Fire
P.O. Box 1206
Rhinelander, WI 54501